Tuesday, December 19, 2006
SBP's theory of patriotism
Oscar Wilde said, "Patriotism is a virtue of the vicious". I don't feel there is anything wrong about being patriotic to the country you live in, but what's dangerous is when your patriotism is so strong that you deny what is wrong with it, or that it is even capable of erring.
I feel Americans are the most guilty of this. They call the United States the best country in the world to live in. But why? It is the only industrialized nation without guaranteed health care. The crime and murder rates are through the roof. There are states without worker's compensation. Ghettos and gated communities show the huge gap between the rich & poor. It seems that these conditions are almost accepted as being a normal way to live, and while I feel America has numerous rights guaranteed in their laws for their citizens to flourish, they still have a way to go to be the #1 nation in the world to live.
Canada seems to be the opposite. The fiasco with the selection of the flag-bearer for the Winter Olympics was embarrassing. And in the previous Summer Olympics, Canada chose a silver-medal winning Judo fighter from Quebec who is an admitted separatist to carry the flag. They could have chosen the gold-medal winning wrestler from the 2000 Olympics who was in tears as the flag was raised as the anthem played. But, almost as an apology to appease Quebecers, they chose the 2nd place separatist.
The only thing I can recall in recent memory that touched on the patriotism of Canada was an ad for a Canadian beer. Can we not be proud of our accomplishments with health care, education, taking care of the poor and elderly and our general high standards of living? There's not one place in Ottawa where I fear to walk, and I can tell you the same thing cannot be said in any major city in the USA. Canada isn't perfect, but we seem to take for granted about how good we have it here.
Maybe I'm going off on tangents, but you get my meaning. I'm very proud of being Canadian, but I'm not afraid to say, "Hey, change that", either.
I feel Americans are the most guilty of this. They call the United States the best country in the world to live in. But why? It is the only industrialized nation without guaranteed health care. The crime and murder rates are through the roof. There are states without worker's compensation. Ghettos and gated communities show the huge gap between the rich & poor. It seems that these conditions are almost accepted as being a normal way to live, and while I feel America has numerous rights guaranteed in their laws for their citizens to flourish, they still have a way to go to be the #1 nation in the world to live.
Canada seems to be the opposite. The fiasco with the selection of the flag-bearer for the Winter Olympics was embarrassing. And in the previous Summer Olympics, Canada chose a silver-medal winning Judo fighter from Quebec who is an admitted separatist to carry the flag. They could have chosen the gold-medal winning wrestler from the 2000 Olympics who was in tears as the flag was raised as the anthem played. But, almost as an apology to appease Quebecers, they chose the 2nd place separatist.
The only thing I can recall in recent memory that touched on the patriotism of Canada was an ad for a Canadian beer. Can we not be proud of our accomplishments with health care, education, taking care of the poor and elderly and our general high standards of living? There's not one place in Ottawa where I fear to walk, and I can tell you the same thing cannot be said in any major city in the USA. Canada isn't perfect, but we seem to take for granted about how good we have it here.
Maybe I'm going off on tangents, but you get my meaning. I'm very proud of being Canadian, but I'm not afraid to say, "Hey, change that", either.
Comments:
<< Home
Couldn't agree more BP. I am a huge patriot and believe that as a patriot we should be proud our great country and being a patriotic citizen we must be vocal on what isn’t working be it a piece of legislation or the politician who wrote it looking for more votes in the short-term. Or maybe it is making sure that we have our civil liberties in tact and so on.
Public participation, among other things, help to keep the country great. Most of us take these things for granted. Like you said the divide between rich and poor is huge. Most of the US that believe they are the best country are those who have and as bush said “the haves and the have mores”.
My Aunt and Uncle in Atlanta are bush voters why? Bc he appeals to the “American Dream” –whatever that is anymore- where my Uncle has an Avalanche, Suburban, Mercedes CLK 350, beach house, sea doos, ski boat…. And a huge home in a gated community. They are part of the reason why I wrote the article about censoring your child’s music among other things.
Now go and ask my sister in Syracuse NY how much she loves the US right now as she gets 6 WEEKS for maternity leave…I am sure that she would have preferred one less tank in Iraq and had some quality time with her child, wait I thought the US was all about family and family values, oh yeah it depends on who your family is or how much they make.
Public participation, among other things, help to keep the country great. Most of us take these things for granted. Like you said the divide between rich and poor is huge. Most of the US that believe they are the best country are those who have and as bush said “the haves and the have mores”.
My Aunt and Uncle in Atlanta are bush voters why? Bc he appeals to the “American Dream” –whatever that is anymore- where my Uncle has an Avalanche, Suburban, Mercedes CLK 350, beach house, sea doos, ski boat…. And a huge home in a gated community. They are part of the reason why I wrote the article about censoring your child’s music among other things.
Now go and ask my sister in Syracuse NY how much she loves the US right now as she gets 6 WEEKS for maternity leave…I am sure that she would have preferred one less tank in Iraq and had some quality time with her child, wait I thought the US was all about family and family values, oh yeah it depends on who your family is or how much they make.
To quote another great poet, "Get Rich or Die Tryin". That's the American dream as interpreted for the last half century, anyways.
The fabric of their society is stitched with a sense of Meritocracy. If you made a lot of money doing something, you've taken advantage of the dream that America offered, and should reward yourself with the finer things in life. If you're poor? You didn't try hard enough.
When I visited the Anne Frank museum in Amsterdam a few years back, there was a very interesting exhibit on patriotism and the slippery slope to nationalism that was basically the blueprint to Germany's frenzy in the 20's, 30's and 40's. They basically show how patriotism (loving your country) could quickly become extreme nationalism (hating other people's countries because it's not like yours) depending on the socio-economic pressures put upon the people and government. In Germany, it was all the economic and political sanctions put upon them after World War I, coupled with the emergence of a leader like Adolf who appealed to the masses because A) he represented strength amongst a surging fear-controlled society and B) he wasn't going to let the other nations of world kick Germans around anymore...
Flash forward 50+ years, and you see the U.S. following a surprisingly similar model where fear-mongoring has pushed citizens into voting for Bush because he represented the safest option to protect the best nation on earth from all it's enemies.
Only the naive think this is a new phenomenon though. The threat of Terrorism in the US is just "Coke Blak" to the Communist Threat's "Coca Cola Classic."
Funny how the fear and panic always happen close to election times, eh? How many "amber alerts" have you heard in the last couple of years?
Sorry BP, your blog's probably on a watch list now. :)
Oh, and one last note about that Anne Frank exhibit: Canada and Australia were both extremely high on the list of patriotism based on the results of their interactive surveys they ran at the museum. The final warning in that exhibit is that it's okay to love your country, just don't start hating others because it's not like yours.
Post a Comment
The fabric of their society is stitched with a sense of Meritocracy. If you made a lot of money doing something, you've taken advantage of the dream that America offered, and should reward yourself with the finer things in life. If you're poor? You didn't try hard enough.
When I visited the Anne Frank museum in Amsterdam a few years back, there was a very interesting exhibit on patriotism and the slippery slope to nationalism that was basically the blueprint to Germany's frenzy in the 20's, 30's and 40's. They basically show how patriotism (loving your country) could quickly become extreme nationalism (hating other people's countries because it's not like yours) depending on the socio-economic pressures put upon the people and government. In Germany, it was all the economic and political sanctions put upon them after World War I, coupled with the emergence of a leader like Adolf who appealed to the masses because A) he represented strength amongst a surging fear-controlled society and B) he wasn't going to let the other nations of world kick Germans around anymore...
Flash forward 50+ years, and you see the U.S. following a surprisingly similar model where fear-mongoring has pushed citizens into voting for Bush because he represented the safest option to protect the best nation on earth from all it's enemies.
Only the naive think this is a new phenomenon though. The threat of Terrorism in the US is just "Coke Blak" to the Communist Threat's "Coca Cola Classic."
Funny how the fear and panic always happen close to election times, eh? How many "amber alerts" have you heard in the last couple of years?
Sorry BP, your blog's probably on a watch list now. :)
Oh, and one last note about that Anne Frank exhibit: Canada and Australia were both extremely high on the list of patriotism based on the results of their interactive surveys they ran at the museum. The final warning in that exhibit is that it's okay to love your country, just don't start hating others because it's not like yours.
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]